Member Since: 11 Sep 2016
Location: Marnoch
Posts: 4244
Froogle-Yorkshireman wrote:
nigethecat wrote:
After my above post I spoke with someone else in the local town this morning... his 2015 D4 is in having a new engine fitted... 140k miles.... full service history...
Did you happen to discuss the cost? Are JLR contributing?
I've suggested he contact JLR but currently he hasn't approached them and is going for a used engine out of a car that's only done 40k... I think with the mileage on his current car JLR will simply say "no" but nothing ventured... the total he said was £7.5k with the engine from Kent 4x4 breakers...I want to see the sweets before I get into your windowless van... I'm not stupid!
Corris Grey D4 Commercial SE 2016
Zermatt Sliver 2007 D3 SE manual (gone)
Indus Silver D4 HSE 2015 (gone)
Bonatti Grey D3 HSE 2006 (gone)
White D3 S (LHD) 2007 (gone)
Firenze Red D4 HSE 2014 (gone)
Black RRS 3.6TDV8 2008 (gone)
Rusty Green Defender 110 1997 (gone)
Black FL2 HSE 2013 (gone)
8th Mar 2022 7:29 pm
Matty 2332
Member Since: 02 Dec 2008
Location: West Yorkshire
Posts: 670
Are they really as bad as others I dont know - Ford transits suffered with something similar. I read somewhere that its actually less than 2% of Discos suffer with broken cranks, if the figure was higher it would trigger a recall. I'm not in anyway validating this, rather repeating what I have read somewhere else. Its also worth remembering that joining forums such as this, as excellent as it is, one of the main points reported are people having issues with theirs, that's why a lot of people join such forums - for advice on a problem. Just enjoy the cars for what they are - great fun motors
8th Mar 2022 7:59 pm
popsdosh
Member Since: 09 Nov 2009
Location: cambs
Posts: 442
Froogle-Yorkshireman wrote:
nigethecat wrote:
After my above post I spoke with someone else in the local town this morning... his 2015 D4 is in having a new engine fitted... 140k miles.... full service history...
Did you happen to discuss the cost? Are JLR contributing?
A rebuilt JLR short engine will be £13k minimum fitted plus most likely two new turbos! Not exactly small change . Must admit those that belittle the issue must think the failure rate is acceptable and also have not had to contend with the issue. I hope they never have to or they may feel differently about it.
Its an issue that JLR have allowed to carry over in to the D5 , they seem happy to pick up the early failures as the higher mileage ones they can turn their back on.
8th Mar 2022 10:07 pm
DG Site Moderator
Member Since: 12 Dec 2005
Location: The Gaff
Posts: 50978
But there is an acceptable failure rate because that is the reality, all marques have it 21 year LR veteran > D2 GS 2003 > D3 S 2006 > D3 HSE 2009 > D4 HSE 2013 > D4 HSE 2015 > D5 HSE 2018 > DS HSE R-Dynamic P300e 2021
8th Mar 2022 11:01 pm
popsdosh
Member Since: 09 Nov 2009
Location: cambs
Posts: 442
Please give an example of any other premium car manufacturer with as high a failure rate of such an expensive to replace component! That have not made any effort to rectify that problem . If it had been a safety component they would have been forced into a recall a long time ago.
Ford stopped using that lump ages ago until they came up with a fix. Why didnt JLR start using the revised set up? Maybe they factor in that they may only end up having to pick up the cost of a small percentage of failures ! However for those that dont get goodwill face the prospect of having to write off what they paid for the vehicle or spend up to its value again to repair often whilst still paying off the finance outstanding.
In China and I believe Australia JLR are legally obliged to replace these engines FOC
8th Mar 2022 11:53 pm
DG Site Moderator
Member Since: 12 Dec 2005
Location: The Gaff
Posts: 50978
What do you think the 'high failure rate' is and how does it compare to others? I suggest you do your research.21 year LR veteran > D2 GS 2003 > D3 S 2006 > D3 HSE 2009 > D4 HSE 2013 > D4 HSE 2015 > D5 HSE 2018 > DS HSE R-Dynamic P300e 2021
9th Mar 2022 2:52 am
Dave T
Member Since: 03 Jul 2009
Location: Glasgow
Posts: 6910
popsdosh wrote:
Please give an example of any other premium car manufacturer with as high a failure rate of such an expensive to replace component!
Porsche bore score?
Off course it’s bad, I had to replace my D3 engine way back in about 2010 or so, yes it is a painful experience, but I have since had 2 D4s and a RRS with 3.0l diesel, what else do you buy? I even tried an Audi SQ 5 before buying the RRS, sat in it but didn’t even bother starting it!Joined the BMWX5 45e group
1994 Defender 90
2015 RRS Corris Grey/Black roof
2016 D4 Graphite Santorini Black
2012 D4 XS Orkney Grey
2005 D3 S Maya Gold
Convoy for Heroes 2011
9th Mar 2022 6:33 am
Robert SausageTrousers
Member Since: 09 Aug 2015
Location: Cornwall
Posts: 467
Yep, bore score on the 997.1 911's, I have one, as well as the Disco, so I guess I just like living on the edge!
I've had my 911 for 4 years and it's been faultless, it had suffered bore scoring just prior to me purchasing it so had just been rebuilt, but there's nothing to say it won't happen again, it was on 49k when it happened last time and it's now on 76k.
Crank shaft failure, can it happen? yes. Is it a given? no. I would never have one of these cars without a full LR warranty, my car was bought from my local dealer and has never been anywhere other than there since I bought it. If the crank goes i'll expect them to cover 100% of the cost. You tend to find that there'll be certain people who post in each and every thread on the subject which can make it seem like it occurs more than it does in reality (this happens on the 911 forums with bore score, same people posting all the time about it, some of which haven't even had the issue!).
This is my 3rd Disco4, my first one had crank shaft failure at 82k miles and wasn't covered by a warranty.
As others have said, there's nothing on the market that compares to the D4, so I'm sticking with mine for a while.
Please give an example of any other premium car manufacturer with as high a failure rate of such an expensive to replace component!
Do Morris Marina kingpins count ?
Used to regularly see them with one near-horizontal front wheel, usually on the exit of a roundabout.
9th Mar 2022 4:54 pm
PROFSR G
Member Since: 06 Mar 2017
Location: Lost
Posts: 5042
Marina's don't count Dean as it was the every single component of that car that failed....
except the crank. yµ (idµ - eAµ) ψ=mψ
9th Mar 2022 5:30 pm
Doug2507
Member Since: 13 Mar 2022
Location: Aberdeen
Posts: 12
So motoreasy seems reasonable to protect costs for crank failure but you're still 50% contribution when over 90k on the clock. They specifically state component contribution so not sure that's verbatim or labour contribution as well. 2 things that arent specifically mentioned in what they cover are turbos and anything suspension related (compressor, strut units). Offsetting cost of warranty per year against engine replacement still makes sense in my book and will be taking out a policy with them pending answers to a couple of questions.
16th Mar 2022 9:56 am
D4mation
Member Since: 29 Jul 2011
Location: Ruralshire
Posts: 593
Like most warranty companies Motoreasy limit any claim to the value of the car.
I don't know what the likes of Oval Autos charge for a crankshaft job but I suspect it would be a close run thing where my 10 year old 62K D4 is concerned.MY12 D4 HSE Ipanema Sand
20th Mar 2022 12:02 pm
galwaygreen
Member Since: 30 Oct 2011
Location: plymouth
Posts: 6525
certainly hurts if its your car...can INSTANTLY writes you off...hey ho kick on its landrover
21st Mar 2022 12:14 am
OvalAutos
Member Since: 28 Dec 2018
Location: Cradley Heath
Posts: 382
All the parts to reman the engine are available, even genuine bearings if thats what you want.
A brand new JLR short engine starts at £4,820. A genuine JLR reman* full (bare) engine starts at £6,522. Anyone that's fitted a JLR reman engine will be as suspicious as me as to what they have reclaimed from a previous engine. It all looks brand new to me - go figure!
As has been mentioned many times, the number of failures is very small compared to the number manufactured over the years. People come to forums generally for 2 reasons; to seek advice/help on problem or moan about a problem. You don't get many posts singing the praises of their cars.
As to why some fail, it's just down to luck IMHO.
*I say a genuine JLR reman engine, but it's actually built https://www.autocraftsg.com/ I've been up to see their factory in Grantham and it looks very good.Joe
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
